The title “Lincoln” might be misleading, because while there is obviously a focus on the legendary, great man, the spotlight remains on the last months of his life and the fight to pass the 13th Amendment outlawing slavery into law. As unthinkable as this might be today, the movie proposes that there was actually a great danger that slavery would continue after the Civil War. After all, some people reasoned, they were in the final months and victory was inevitable. Why not make this compromise that would probably save thousands of lives? The movie tries to provide an answer as it shows how slavery was such a deeply ingrained part of the South that it would be unthinkable for the Confederacy to willingly surrender their human chattel, as well as the prejudice of many in the Union that couldn't even bring themselves to acknowledge them as fellow human beings.
So how do you bring such a larger than life man to the screen, yet also depict him as someone human and recognizable, while still undeniably compelling even as he struggles with what could easily become boring legal procedure? Well, for starters, you bring in an actor like Daniel Day-Lewis to do the aforementioned work of making him human and compelling. He has something in common with Meryl Streep in that he doesn't so much embody his characters; he channels them. In his capable hands we aren't merely watching a movie about Lincoln, we feel like we see the man himself.
He is old and bent, but by no means broken, and very aware of the moral and historical weight on his shoulders. He also has his little idiosyncrasies, such as when he tells quaint, simple stories to illustrate his point to a captive audience. And of course, he and those around him have paid a price for their services to the greater good. “Lincoln” shows that it's smart and subtle enough to make you feel the burden he and his wife Mary Todd (Sally Field) have had to bear, as well as show the process of bringing the 13th Amendment to existence without being overdramatic.
That said, don't expect an uncompromising moral crusader. This Lincoln is a pragmatist who recognizes that he will have to make a few moral and legal compromises in the service of the greater good. Bribes? Nonsense, he's just merely offering a few nice jobs to those who are willing to give him the votes he wants. And if someone who was working for him offered money, well then he wasn't aware of it. And he decides to avoid the issue of giving slaves full equality after they are freed. Apparently, even those who hated slavery couldn't wrap their minds around that. (What's next, women voting??!!!)
And those who bemoan the corruption and partisanship of today might feel that our situation isn't so bad after they witness the dirty tricks that were required even for the best causes, as well as the insults that would routinely get thrown around by the opposing sides of a debate. Oh, and thank goodness that it took so long to actual fire and reload a gun back in the day. (A new sense of perspective can be a good thing.)
Naturally, we all know how this fight will end, and it's to the movie's credit that it still feels uplifting and even suspenseful. We see the price the nation paid to rid ourselves of a great evil when Lincoln travels to the battlefield and sees the countless bodies on both sides. After all, when you decide to right such a heinous wrong, even a compromise will result in some sort of bloodshed.
I only wish that they had chosen to focus on other aspects of Lincoln's life. There is not a single flashback to found in this film, which feels like an real shame with all this assembled talent (which includes Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Tommy Lee Jones, John Hawkes, and Jackie Earle Haley) and Lincoln's fascinating history. However, this is no fault of the film, merely the result of a movie that is so wonderfully packed with details that it would be impossible to show such care to the entirety of Lincoln's career. It should be stated that what they do focus on is sheer perfection.
Grade: A+
$$andSense
3:21 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
The man already had lost two kids (which would send most everyday people over the edge), had a spouse equally or more distraught over this and other political issues (her family had owned slaves), was dealing as #1 over the civil war and had a highly contentious congress to control. Don't need to see the movie to understand this. Just read a few books to understand that a person like Abe Lincoln does not come along every day and for the most part we have not seen leadership in the US for a long time that can match the fortitude that this man and what he had to deal with. He was old for the time in the 1860's, but his life’s experience would have likely done in people today in their 40's. I loved the movie as much as I have read about this great person. I do not believe history was exaggerated in the film like so much of most Hollywood films.
ann
8:15 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
The Lincoln Movie is Propaganda
so that means it’s the Oscar winner this year
Personally, for me, Mr. Spielberg’s movie career ended with the brilliant “Jaws.”
$$andSense
9:31 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Propaganda? ann, you think this is made up stuff? I admit that Spielberg has taken a lot of artistic freedom on some of his other work, but not on this one. How old are you to post such an outrageous comment? Do (did) they not teach history where you went to school or you have no interest in history? What is this country coming to with such stupid comments as such. Get your butt to your local library, better yet, you can use the same keyboard to research Lincoln's biography. Wow!
Greg
11:27 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Ann, What cause would be served by the "Propaganda"?
ann
12:44 pm on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Wow, what a bad film. This is a two and a half hour long colossal bore that reeks of self-importance, but comes off as indulgent and lacking the gravitas it so obviously aspires to. I can't remember when I've ever seen a film when I felt so aware of the well-known actors playing the roles … look, there's Tommy Lee Jones in a wig, and there's James Spader playing a rascal, Daniel Day-Lewis as the big man, and OMG, Sally Field as Mrs. Lincoln (look at those wrinkles!).
I know I'm in the minority but this film is very boring. The first hour drags on and on explaining the 13th Amendment and it could have been edited down to a 10 or 15 minute seen.
Bren
9:17 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
The death toll of the Civil War was staggering (newest estimates 750,000 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/03/science/civil-war-toll-up-by-20-percent-in-new-estimate.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0). The number of injuries/maimings also staggering (A Civil War ancestor received a wound that never healed right and troubled him all his life, for example). Corruption from government contractors sent Union soldiers to war with poor quality armament, shoes, horses (though the government paid for high quality), adding to the death and casualty lists. The corruption grew to unprecedented levels after the War, leading to more social unrest and casualties.
Despite all of this (and the fact that many Northerners wanted slaves freed but not living in the North), Lincoln's decision not to accept the Crittenden Compromise to avoid war was the right one. The Crittenden Compromise included the permanent, unalterable right to own slaves in the states that already allowed it (http://www.tulane.edu/~latner/CrittendenComp.html). The foundation of war was laid in the U.S. Constitution, when the Founding Fathers chose to avoid dealing with the issue.
I haven't seen the movie yet but I plan to do so.
Greg
11:20 am on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Here is a preview:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4S8NmHadEko
Bren
12:17 pm on Friday, January 11, 2013
; )
ann
12:48 pm on Wednesday, January 9, 2013
This movie simply put should not have been made, there just isn't enough content in the story to justify making a movie out of it, every scene seemed to be just a bunch of old codgers discussing the impact of the 13th amendment. I could just as easily read this story in 5 pages in just about any American history book and saved myself the pain of watching the strained acting performances from just about everyone in this picture, Do not go into this movie expecting to learn about Abraham Lincoln's life. You will be hugely disappointed.